A good steak doesn't need sauce

Someone on X asked steak eaters to pick a side. A1 or 57?

A lot of the replies said the same thing I would say. If the steak is cooked right, you don’t need either.

I am not here to rank bottles. I don’t think that is the real question. The question is whether the steak can stand on its own.

Sliced steak in a copper pan at SW Steakhouse, Wynn Palace

© Vinko. Sliced steak in a copper pan at SW Steakhouse, Wynn Palace.

I already care about the cook. I have written about why a steak still looks wrong without a crust. Pink in the middle is only half of it. I want a real sear: brown, crisp, worth cutting into. Pink inside, without blood coming out on the plate. When that is missing, a sauce can hide it. A weak crust. A missed temperature. The bottle does the work the pan should have done.

When the kitchen gets it right, I want the meat. Salt. The fat. Maybe a quiet side. I have said the same thing about dry-aged ribeye at the bar. The steak should do the talking.

I am not policing anyone else’s plate. If you like a sauce, that is your dinner. I just don’t think a well-cooked steak is asking for one.

If I reach for a sauce, I ask whether the cook missed, not which bottle to use.

More from Blog